No ethics, no justice

Opinion
Tue, 17 Nov 2026 10:43 GMT
There can be no justice without ethics. From the non-implementation of ECtHR judgments concerning the Turkish Minority of Western Thrace to restrictions on freedom of association and religious representation, respect for citizens' rights must be reflected in the actions of the state.
No ethics, no justice

If we are expected to trust the state's justice system, we want to see that trust reciprocated through the implementation of court judgments and respect for the will of citizens.

How can a state explain justice to a person when it cannot tolerate hearing that person's identity expressed in their own words?

We have been asking this question for years in Western Thrace. The same issue arises in the name of an association in İskeçe (Xanthi) and in the will of the minority to choose its religious representative in Gümülcine (Komotini). To what extent can the Greek state decide how its own citizens define themselves and who represents them?

This is precisely where the relationship between justice and ethics becomes apparent. The state has authority. Citizens, meanwhile, have legal avenues through which they can seek their rights. When the state delays fulfilling a judgment delivered at the end of those legal proceedings, who pays the price? People who spend a lifetime waiting at courthouse doors.

Why should the name of an association be feared?
The process that resulted in the dissolution of the İskeçe Turkish Union was brought before the European Court of Human Rights. In 2008, the Court ruled that Greece had violated the right to freedom of association. The rejection of registration applications submitted by the Rodopi Turkish Women's Cultural Association and the Minority Youth Association, which sought to be established in the Evros region, was also found to constitute a violation of the same freedom. In 2014 and 2021, the Council of Europe's Committee of Ministers called on Greece to implement these judgments.

Now, how are we supposed to explain this to a citizen living in İskeçe? They spent years seeking justice simply because they put their own identity on an association's signboard. They were vindicated in Strasbourg. Then they had to wait once again for that judgment to be implemented.

The state expects citizens to comply with court judgments. Citizens, in turn, expect the state to treat judgments issued against it with the same seriousness. What is excessive about this expectation?

In Gümülcine, İbrahim Şerif, whom the Turkish minority had elected as its mufti, was convicted on the grounds that he had acted in the capacity of a mufti. In 1999, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that this conviction had violated freedom of religion. The Court noted that there was no indication that Şerif had attempted to exercise the judicial or administrative powers assigned to a mufti by law. Acting as the religious leader of a community that voluntarily followed him did not justify imposing a criminal penalty.

If you intervene through criminal courts in a community's choice of whom to recognise as its religious leader, what kind of trust can you inspire in those people? The state's duty is to ensure that citizens with different preferences can live together. The first condition for this is to respect the people who make those choices.

A door closed to two citizens in Bosnia and Herzegovina
In Bosnia and Herzegovina, Dervo Sejdić, who is of Roma origin, and Jakob Finci, who is of Jewish origin, were unable to stand for election to their country's three-member Presidency or the House of Peoples, the upper chamber of parliament. The constitutional order established by the Dayton Peace Agreement reserved these positions for Bosniaks, Croats and Serbs. In 2009, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that preventing the two citizens from standing for election because of their ethnic origins constituted discrimination.

The Dayton arrangement was established to secure peace following a devastating war. But if we determine who gets to have a say in that peace by looking at the family into which a person was born, how can everyone trust that peace? In the case brought by Sejdić and Finci, an obstacle stood in the way of citizens seeking to stand for the country's highest office. In İskeçe, the obstacle arose when people sought to give an association their own name. In both places, citizens had to go to court to exercise a right while openly expressing their identity.

Germany and Denmark chose a different path
In 1955, Germany and Denmark issued the Bonn and Copenhagen Declarations concerning the Danish and German minorities living on either side of their border. The principle they adopted was clear: people would be free to express which minority and culture they belonged to, and public authorities would not question that declaration.

Looking at this from Western Thrace, one question comes to mind. If the state can respect a citizen in Germany identifying as Danish and a citizen in Denmark identifying as German, why should a Greek citizen in İskeçe not be allowed to use the word "Turkish" in the name of their association? A person's ability to openly express their sense of belonging is also part of living as an equal citizen of that country.

On whose behalf does the approval of one of our own count?
There is also an aspect that we need to discuss openly within our own community. Everyone has the right to think differently, meet with the state and make their own choices. The ethic problem begins when public authorities meet with some members of our community and present their views as if they constitute the consent of the entire minority. Meeting with a few people and ignoring the objections of the rest does not eliminate the question of who actually consents to the decision.

Did the person invited to a meeting attend in their own capacity or on behalf of an organisation? If they attended on behalf of an organisation, under what authority did they speak? Who is affected by the decision, and where is the voice of those people? We all have the right to ask these questions. Anyone speaking on behalf of the minority must also be able to explain from whom they received that authority.

We are citizens of this country. We want to be able to choose the name of our association ourselves in İskeçe and freely make decisions concerning our religious life in Gümülcine. If we are expected to trust the state's justice system, we want to see that trust reciprocated through the implementation of court judgments and respect for the will of citizens.

A state's commitment to justice becomes clear especially after a judgment has been delivered against it. At the end of a case that has taken years from a citizen's life, the state must also be able to fulfil its own responsibilities. Without ethics, there can be no justice.

Related News

MILLET MEDIA OE.
BİLAL BUDUR & CENGİZ ÖMER KOLLEKTİF ŞİRKETİ.
Address: Miaouli 7-9, Xanthi 67100, GREECE.
Tel: +30 25410 77968.
Email: info@milletgazetesi.gr.